Inkbound Inkbound
Guide

Self-Publishing vs Traditional Publishing: Which Is Right for Your Novel?

Last updated: November 2026

A green typewriter on a wooden desk, next to two pens and a stack of typed pages

The manuscript is finished. Now comes the scary question: send it to publishers, or publish it yourself? Self-publishing vs traditional publishing isn't a contest with one winner. The two paths pay you differently and ask very different work of you. I haven't done either yet: my own novel is still in progress, and this question is waiting for me too. So I went looking for real numbers, including the Canadian ones most articles on the subject leave out.

In short: choose traditional publishing if you want professional support, a place in bookstores and to pay nothing to get published, even if it means waiting and giving up some control. Choose self-publishing if you want to decide everything and publish fast, while paying for editing and the cover yourself and doing your own promotion.

Self-publishing vs traditional publishing at a glance

Traditional publishingSelf-publishing
Who pays for productionThe publisherYou
Your share per book7.5% to 15% of the list price in print, 25% of net receipts on ebooksUp to 70% on an ebook
TimelineMonths to hear back, then often a year or more before releaseA few weeks, at your own pace
ControlShared (title, cover, release date)Total
BookstoresThrough the publisher's distributorHard: mostly online sales
SelectionTough: lots of rejectionsNone

How traditional publishing works

You send your manuscript out and wait to hear whether someone wants to publish it. Who you send it to depends on where you live. The big publishers in the US and the UK rarely read unsolicited manuscripts: you first need a literary agent, who then pitches your book to editors. Agents usually take 15% of your earnings on domestic deals, and a legitimate agent never charges you upfront. In Canada, many smaller presses accept submissions directly from authors. Our directory of Canadian publishers lists 51 of them outside Quebec, with the languages they accept and a link to their submission page.

If your manuscript is accepted, you sign a publishing contract. The publisher handles editing, proofreading, layout, the cover, printing and distribution. It also takes the financial risk: if the book doesn't sell, the publisher loses money, not you.

In exchange, you license rights to your text for a period set by the contract, and you earn royalties on every copy sold. How much depends on the format and the country:

  • United States: the Authors Guild's model trade book contract uses 7.5% of the list price for a trade paperback, around 10% to 15% for a hardcover (the rate climbs as sales grow), and 25% of the publisher's net receipts for an ebook.
  • English Canada: 10% of the list price is the usual benchmark for a trade book. Half the authors in a federal survey reported exactly that rate on their latest contract.
  • Quebec: the writers' union (UNEQ) recommends a sliding scale: 10% of the retail price for the first 5,000 copies, 12% up to 10,000, then 15%.

Many contracts also include an advance, money paid before release and deducted from your future royalties. If the book doesn't sell enough to cover it, you usually don't have to pay it back: you simply earn nothing more until royalties pass the advance (that's called earning out).

Read the subsidiary rights clause too. Audiobook, translation and film rights can be licensed along with the book, or kept by you. They are sometimes worth more than the book itself.

The downsides are well known. There are a lot of rejections, often with no explanation. The wait is long: months for an answer (longer if you need an agent first), then often more than a year of work before the book hits shelves. And you won't always get the final say on the title or cover.

How self-publishing works

You publish the book yourself, usually through print-on-demand and ebook platforms: Amazon KDP, Kobo Writing Life, IngramSpark or Draft2Digital. The book is only printed when a reader orders it. No boxes of unsold copies in your basement.

You keep your rights and make every decision. The catch: you also become the publisher. Editing, cover, layout, pricing, the book description, promotion, all of it is on you. So are the costs: professional editing and a good cover often run several hundred dollars, sometimes more.

On the income side, Amazon pays 35% or 70% of an ebook's price. The 70% rate only applies if the price falls within Amazon's range (roughly $2.99 to $9.99 US). For a paperback, Amazon pays 60% of the list price minus the printing cost, which depends on the page count.

Two practical steps people often forget:

  • The ISBN, the number that identifies your book. In Canada it's free: Library and Archives Canada issues it (BAnQ does for publishers based in Quebec). In the US, ISBNs are sold by Bowker: $125 for one, $295 for a block of ten. Since each format (paperback, ebook, hardcover) needs its own number, the block is usually the better deal. Platforms often offer a free ISBN, but then they are listed as the publisher, not you.
  • Legal deposit: in many countries, publishers (including self-published authors) must send copies of a printed book to the national library. In Quebec, that means two copies to BAnQ within seven days of publication. Check the rules where you live.

What 1,000 copies pays you

Take a debut novel and 1,000 copies sold, a solid result for a first book:

  • US trade paperback at $17.99, 7.5% royalty: about $1.35 per copy, so roughly $1,350.
  • Canadian trade paperback at $24.95, 10% royalty: about $2.50 per copy, so roughly $2,500.
  • Self-published ebook at $6.99, 70% on Amazon: about $4.90 per sale, so close to $4,900.

That's two to three and a half times more per copy when you self-publish.

On paper, self-publishing wins. Except you have to sell those thousand copies without a sales rep in bookstores or a spot on the new-releases table. And you have to subtract what you paid for editing and the cover. The question that matters becomes: how many books can you sell on your own?

Watch out for vanity publishers

Some companies present themselves as publishers but ask you to pay: "marketing" fees, a required purchase of copies, a "contribution" to printing. That's vanity publishing. It isn't traditional publishing, where the publisher takes the risk, and it isn't self-publishing, where you keep control and the income. You pay, and the company decides.

A traditional publisher never asks you for money. If a contract does, read it twice, and have someone review it before you sign.

Questions to ask yourself before choosing

  • What matters most to you? Seeing your book in bookstores, published by a known house, or keeping control of every decision?
  • How much time can you give to promotion? In self-publishing, writing the book is only half the job.
  • Does your novel fit a clear niche? Romance, fantasy and thrillers often find their readers online. Literary fiction benefits more from booksellers and reviews.
  • What budget can you invest? With traditional publishing, nothing. With self-publishing, whatever a well-made book costs.

Your answers will guide you better than any general advice, including this one.

Can you do both?

Yes. Many authors query publishers or agents first, then turn to self-publishing if the rejections pile up. Others publish some books traditionally and self-publish others, depending on the project. They're called "hybrid" authors.

One caution: a book that's already been self-published is usually less attractive to publishers, since its rights have already been used. If you dream of a publisher, try them before publishing it yourself. Our directories of Canadian publishers and Quebec publishers can help you target the right houses.

Either way: a manuscript that's ready

An editor will read your first pages in a few minutes. So will an online reader, using the free preview. Either way, a text full of repetitions and typos stops right there. Before you send or publish anything, revise in passes (structure first, style later), hunt down your style tics and get beta readers to read it.

That's the stage Inkbound is built for. Its style assistant flags repetitions and weak verbs, the grammar checker catches mistakes, and the version history keeps every state of your chapters while you rework them. Once the text is ready, you can export it to Word or PDF for a submission, or to ePub for a self-publishing platform.

Happy writing!

Frequently asked questions

Can you get traditionally published after self-publishing?

It's possible, especially if the book sold well, but it's harder: its rights have already been used. If a publisher is your goal, submit the manuscript before publishing it yourself.

Does self-publishing cost money?

Publishing on Amazon KDP or Kobo is free, and ISBNs are free in Canada (in the US, Bowker charges $125 for one). But a polished book usually needs professional editing and a cover, which often cost several hundred dollars.

How much does a traditionally published author earn per book?

In the US, about 7.5% of the list price for a trade paperback, 10% to 15% for a hardcover and 25% of net receipts for an ebook. In English Canada, 10% of the list price is the usual benchmark. In Quebec, the UNEQ recommends 10% up to 5,000 copies, 12% up to 10,000, then 15%.

Is vanity publishing the same as self-publishing?

No. With vanity publishing, you pay a company to publish your book and it keeps control. With self-publishing, you are your own publisher: you pay for the services you choose and keep your rights.

Want a clean manuscript, ready for a publisher or for self-publishing? Two full projects, no credit card.
Create my free Inkbound account